CJI Sets Up Three-Member Panel to Investigate While HC Judge Denies Allegations

Key Takeaways

• The CJI formed a three-member inquiry committee to probe allegations against Justice Yashwant Varma.
• Justice Varma has been temporarily relieved of judicial duties during the inquiry.
• The Supreme Court has made all documents and responses public to ensure transparency.
• Justice Varma denies the allegations, calling them part of a malicious conspiracy.
• The outcome of this probe could impact future judicial accountability and disciplinary processes.

Committee Members Include Senior Judges

• Justice Sheel Nagu, Chief Justice of the Punjab & Haryana High Court
• Justice G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice of the Himachal Pradesh High Court
• Justice Anu Sivaraman, Judge of the Karnataka High Court

Judicial Work Withdrawn Temporarily

To maintain neutrality, the Chief Justice of the Delhi High Court has received directions. They should not assign judicial duties to Justice Varma during the inquiry.

Transparency in Inquiry Process

The Supreme Court has ensured public transparency. It has made all inquiry-related documents available on its official website. This includes Justice Varma’s responses.

Seriousness of Allegations and Potential Impact

Legal experts believe this move signals a strong commitment to judicial accountability. The findings of this inquiry may influence future judicial oversight mechanisms and disciplinary actions in the higher judiciary.

Justice Varma Denies Accusations, Claims Conspiracy

Justice Yashwant Varma has categorically denied the allegations, stating that he is being targeted through false accusations and fabricated evidence.

Inconsistencies in the Incident Highlighted by Justice Varma

In his detailed statement, Justice Varma pointed out several suspicious aspects:

• The cash was allegedly found in an unlocked and exposed storeroom near staff quarters. It is an unlikely location for storing large amounts of money.
• During a fire incident, his staff and family were moved away, and no cash was visible upon their return.
• None of his household members or staff were shown any recovered cash or officially informed about a seizure.
• He expressed shock over a video showing burnt currency, calling it suspicious and inconsistent with what he witnessed on-site.

Evidence of Transparent Finances Provided by the Judge

Justice Varma asserted that his family’s financial transactions are entirely legitimate. They are well-documented through banking channels, UPI apps, and credit/debit cards.

Call for Impartial Probe

Justice Varma concluded by calling for a thorough and unbiased investigation. He expressed confidence that truth will prevail. He believes that his reputation, built over years of service, will remain intact.